18 Comments
Oct 31Liked by Rob Stephenson

Thank you! Your photos are great and your research is thorough. I love learning about the borough I live in. 😃

Expand full comment
author

Thanks Dana!

Expand full comment
Oct 31Liked by Rob Stephenson

Spooky! It's so hard to believe the incomprehensible horror of care centers for the disabled even just a few decades ago.

Expand full comment
Oct 31Liked by Rob Stephenson

The place really was awful. There's a good book titled "The Willowbrook Wars" by David and Sheila Rothman published in 1984 that tells the story of Willowbrook in detail and outlines the effort to remove developmentally disabled people from the terrible warehouse-type mental institutions and into the community in New York State. Great read. It's available on Amazon and at some libraries.

Expand full comment
author

Truly. The footage from the Geraldo expose is horrific.

Expand full comment

The thing that struck me about Seabrook and the NY Farm Colony when I snuck in and poked around was how so many things were left intact at the hospital. Glasses and tableware left out, an open book of piano music still on the piano. That was the creepiest part. Granted, that was 20ish years ago and I wonder if it's still like that.

Expand full comment
author

That does sound creepy! When I visited North Brother Island it felt a lot like that. I think the Farm Colony side of the whole compound has been pretty picked over, but I imagine the Sea View side, where I didn't venture, probably has at least some of those stopped in time tableaus left.

Expand full comment
Oct 31·edited Oct 31Liked by Rob Stephenson

Well done, as always, Rob. As a kid, I used to ride the R110 bus to Sea View Hospital and back. To a seven-year-old boy, that entire campus was creepy as heck (and yes, I rode city buses by myself at seven...times were different then!) Meanwhile, my Dad worked as a security guard at the old Willowbrook School after the state partially closed it in the late 1970s. As a teen, I really hated visiting him at work. The place had a very well deserved bad reputation and was even creepier when it was mostly empty by 1980. Fortunately, CUNY took over the site, knocked down many of the buildings, renovated others and built a gorgeous new campus for the College of Staten Island. It's the largest college campus in NYC at over 200 acres and looks more like a New England university than an urban college campus.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks Eddie! Willowbrook sounds like on of those places where the reality is worse than the stories about it. What were your dad's experiences working there? He must have been there when two of the employees went missing. I can't imagine. CSI does look like a nice campus. I wonder how many students there know about the site's past.

Expand full comment
Nov 1·edited Nov 1Liked by Rob Stephenson

Dad didn't work there very long, maybe six months or so in 1980. He said it was just lonely and creepy as the campus was almost empty when the state moved most of the patients into community housing or to other institutions. I got a distinct creepy vibe the few times I visited him at work. Entering the CSI campus today, as nice as it is, still gives me the willies. Doubt many of the students today know Willowbrook's past. Over the last 40 years, Staten Islanders have been fine just forgetting the whole thing. Can't say I blame them.

Expand full comment

From my vantage point, it's entirely possible that Cropsey may have been the inspiration for some of the serial killer movie stars of the 1980s (particularly Freddy Krueger).

Expand full comment
author

Yes! The Burning was originally going to be called the Cropsey Maniac, and another movie that came out right around the same time, Madman, was also based on the Cropsey legend. I think it inspired a lot of different slasher flicks

Expand full comment

This week’s Substack is exactly why you are one of my 2 favorite authors. Excellent work on your research and photographs. Thank you.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you so much Charlotte! Now I’m

Curious who the other one is!

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by Rob Stephenson

Trying to find out more about the Satanic Church of the Process but no luck!

Expand full comment
author

Try process church of the final judgment. A website I just pulled up while sitting in an actual church by the way. not sure how that’s gonna work out for me in the long run.

Expand full comment
Nov 4Liked by Rob Stephenson

Ok when it comes to weird houses Willowbrook beats Mill Basin any day!

Expand full comment
author

🏰

Expand full comment