18 Comments
User's avatar
Jessica Rath's avatar

The image of the old wooden fence was such a relief in the middle of all these monstrosities... What's wrong with people (rhetoric question). I found this post because Anne Kadet linked it in her own impression of this neighborhood -- great complement.

Expand full comment
Mark M's avatar

Gotta go back for christmas lights - it rivals dyker heights

also don't forget the bar mitzvah/wedding center el caribe owned by Michael Cohen's uncle

Expand full comment
Kami Warm's avatar

I’m from Clinton Hill.

I’ve lived in Mill Basin since 2017.

Whatever Christmas lights used to go on here are no more.

Definitely nothing here like what happens currently in Dyker heights. I can think of maybe 5 houses that put up lights worth looking at, and there is no traffic from other neighborhoods coming to see anything over here.

Perhaps this is due to changing demographics in the neighborhood, or perhaps the lights stopped by design in order to keep visitors away.

In any event, if you’re looking for Xmas, Halloween, or any other type of decoration celebration don’t waste your time on Mill Basin. Dyker Heights is definitely still going hard on the decorations wars if you’re into that kind of thing.

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

El caribe! Amazing tip! I’ll definitely go back for Xmas lights. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Nicole's avatar

A totally nutter neighborhood! Loved the time lapse pic of how it got developed.

Entertaining observations, as always!

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

High on the nuttiness for sure! Thanks Nicole!

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

Those houses. Just...wow!!!

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

Remind me not to bill Anthony Casso.

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

I think you are safe!

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

2458 National Drive!!!

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

Next NYC substack meetup?

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

Mr. Rossetti sounds like a charmer.

Expand full comment
Anne Kadet's avatar

“Ferrari piano so that you can play faster” lol

Expand full comment
Kuleigh Baker's avatar

These are quirky!!! I think this might be my favorite neighborhood post so far.

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

Thanks Kuleigh! Definitely a unique place!

Expand full comment
Nat Kalbach's avatar

wow...I am speechless... this neighborhood elevates MacMansions to a whole new level

Expand full comment
Thomas's avatar

Old mill basin is a lot larger than whatever fake realtor map you used

Expand full comment
Rob Stephenson's avatar

I can't win when it comes to these borders! I used google maps for the neighborhood boundaries. I'll be sure to do some more research if/when I cover OMB

Expand full comment